The four anti-pillars of Marxism

Those who don't understand history are doomed to repeat it.... And those who do are doomed to watch in horror as those who don't repeat it. 

In recent years, I've watched in horror Marxism seemingly coming back in fashion, as if we're in the 1920s. Too many people lack the practical experience, theoretical context,  or intelligence to know the lessons of the last 100 years. 

The seven pillars of wisdom in Christianity or the seven pillars of Islam are things you should build on. With Marxism, we have some seductive big ideas that you should not build on. I call them anti-pillars.  I won't explain them since many great people have before. I'll just list them as pointers.

1. Economic calculation problem and the fallacy of central planning.  

It is not just about having better computers or more data. The information in an economic system doesn't exist in one place or time, it is distributed. Furthermore, even if you had it all at once, much of it is not explicitly manifest but rather implicit preferences.

2. The labor theory of value is wrong

It is not just labor vs capital, there is also value and, more subtly there is quality.  If I spend an hour on the piano and Mozart spends an hour, it's one hour of labor. But there is a subjective difference in value. And an objective difference in price that others will pay for it. Finally, there is something that is neither objective nor subjective, beyond dialectics, namely quality.

3. The class struggle is a static one dimensional model, but human economic relationships are dynamic and multidimensional. 

This may have been subtle in the 19th century, but in the 21st century, it should completely obvious.  In fact even in the 20th century, class was often cynically replaced by ethnicity or religion by various revolutionary Marxists hungry for power.

4. A political system based on class struggle necessarily evolves into an escalating war of purity. In this process, the most ruthless sociopaths, the self-appointed revolutionary vanguard, always end up as the rulers. Which is why almost every Marxist state converges on a violent totalitarian government.

If you are ever about to be to be seduced, at least know these anti-pillars, and spend a small amount of time understanding them.